50th IETF PPPEXT Meeting Minutes Thanks to Ross Wheeler for taking these minutes. ---------------------------------------------------- EAP SIM Authentication (Version 1) draft-haverinen-pppext-eap-sim-00.txt Henry Haverinen Presentation Comments: Went over presentation... Questions/Comment: Henry: this is a new EAP type - what is the policy here? Karl: Do your best and we'll set it up. Matt: Key management protocol - passing distributed keys was frowned upon. Please contact Bernard Aboba. Mark: send the AAA AD a question regarding. Mark: Experimental - EAP TLS is already... Matt: Do your draft ask the chair to see if there is consensus to being a standard and see what happens after that. Henry: has the IANA number Matt: remove the word RADIUS Jari: UMTS authentication ? Henry: just for GSM ---------------------------------------------------- Class Extensions for PPP over AAL2 draft-brucet-pppext-ppp-over-aal2-class-00.txt PPP over AAL2 draft-ietf-pppext-ppp-over-aal2-00.txt Bruce Thompson Presentation Comments: Went over presentation... Is there a need for CRC8? Karl: Get rid of it. Questions/Comments: Karl: Can you use PPPMUX? Bruce: would not be applicable... Response: PPPMUX introduces delay. So maybe that's why? Karl: Can you use PPPMUX to reduce ? Bruce: Yes. Question: AAL2 Work item question 4 traffic measurement studies. Bruce: Question 15 - people expecting a specific SID scheduling algorithm Bruce: What next? Karl: Last call? Karl: Anybody object to it being a working group item? Karl: Done -------------------------------------------------------------------------- IP Header Compression over PPP draft-koren-avt-crtp-ipcp-00.txt Tmima Koren Presentation Question: Requesting to accept this as a work group item... Questions/Comments: Karl: Any objections to being a work group item? Karl: Accepted! ----------------------------------------------------------------- Call for Volunteers - document editors, implementation questionnaire. Karl Fox Need to demonstrate two independent implementations Come up afterward and discuss with Karl. It will be posted to the list.